Getting Along With Alcohol

In an earlier entry I wrote about the "art of drinking well." It was an attempt to explain my approach both to drinking and to this blog. In short form, it's about how drinking is simultaneously about the alcohol and not about the alcohol. Yes, it's about all of the nose-taste-color-finish aspects of a good whiskey -- or whatever libation you're hoisting.  And it's about the buzz of the booze (amen for that!). But ultimately and more importantly, drinking, and enjoying Irish whiskey, is more about the sharing of time and tipple with friends, family and other kindred spirits. It's about the fun, the craic.

I bring this up again because it highlights a sometimes hidden barrier to wider enjoyment of Irish whiskey in the US, and elsewhere. There is a common perception that liquor -- and Irish whiskey in particular -- is less about the enjoyment of fine drink, and more about a shortcut to domestic trouble, moral turpitude, cirrhosis of the liver and early death. Or at least a nasty hangover.

I get this perception whenever I discuss Irish whiskey as "a hobby" with acquaintances. If I mention past or planned Irish whiskey tastings the reaction is usually something like "Wow! Are you going to have people sleep on the floor?!" It is assumed that we're going to kill a few bottles of something, start talking or singing loudly and badly, piss in the sink, then stagger off to sleep somewhere. And while I can get reasonably locked and loaded if I want, drinking has morphed into an activity more like eating -- something to be done more pleasurably than prodigiously.

You can drink well with many types of alcohol -- vodka, gin, rum, scotch, port, brandy, wine, beer and others. And any of those can be associated with overindulgence. But I can enjoy a glass or two of those and not get the same, almost reflexively negative reaction I get if I say I'm drinking Irish whiskey. Indeed, the others -- scotch and port in particular -- seem to convey some level of sophistication. But Irish? Nope. The reaction is far more likely to be either that I like throat-ripping rotgut, or, that I'm drinking to get drunk.

Ironically, some of the hardest negative attitudes about Irish whiskey are in Ireland itself.  That stems from the country's tumultuous history with alcohol. There's national pride in the product, but many of the bartenders and other natives I spoke with in Ireland didn't know much about Irish whiskey, and some didn't drink at all. One evening in Galway, I committed a minor social faux pas by suggesting to my new-best-friend-for-a-night -- a local named Dominic -- that we switch to a whiskey after a few pints. He scowled faintly, shook his head as if I had proposed that we snort heroin, thought for a moment, then compromised on a hot whiskey (aka, hot toddy). Already into his fourth or fifth cider by the time he and I met, Dominic was no teetotaler. But whiskey to him was baaaaaad stuff.

Irish-Americans too have a rocky relationship with alcohol in fact, in anecdotes and by reputation. But having problems with alcohol is hardly unique either to the Irish or Irish-Americans, nor is Irish whiskey uniquely abused. Even so, it's that combination of fact and fiction that underlies the perception that "Irish = Drunk," and by association "Irish Whiskey = Drunk."

Part of the fun of introducing folks to the enjoyment of Irish whiskey is challenging that perception by opening their eyes and mouths to the range of good, really good and excellent brands available. Their perceptions begin to shift, from Irish whiskey being a get-hammered "drunk drink" to being a really good drinker's drink. I like to hear after a tasting that someone went out and bought a bottle of Jameson 12, Red Breast 12, Midleton or something else that tickled their fancy. The relative lack of awareness of Irish whiskey lends it a certain best-kept-secret status to those "in the know."

But don't get me wrong: I don't mean to imply that we start to portray Irish whiskey drinking as an exclusive, pinkie-in-the-air, ascot-or-pearls-wearing activity where we sit around talking about how our ponies did at the track and my-what-a-lovely-job-your-gardeners-did-on-the-front-promenade. Instead, I think that a natural perception of Irish whiskey is a midpoint between having your nose in the gutter and your nose in the air.  It's about enjoying the whiskey, the talk, the banter, the music, the camaraderie and the company. I use the Irish  "craic" (you could also just say "fun") because it captures those elements in a single word, and, of course, it's in context of the subject at hand.

So, keep spreading the good word and sharing the good dram. You'll be adding to the ranks of people who appreciate Irish whiskey, and maybe even find a new drinking companion or two. And, of course, the craic'll be mighty.

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this entry.
Comments

  • 10/31/2009 8:38 AM Patrick Costello wrote:
    Really good post; very well-written. You touched on the problems with drinking in this country; how so many Americans swing wildly between teetotaler and lampshade-on-the-head drunk. Simply enjoying a hard liquor drink on its own merits is becoming a rare thing. I was at a social club and I guy I know casually asked what I was drinking and I told him "gin." He said, only half-joking, "what are you, a drunk?" It became a running joke, him telling people "watch out for this guy, all he drinks is gin and Irish whiskey." It's also funny considering I'm always well-behaved but this guy gets flush-faced and loud after a few. But that's the perception you mentioned; the guy with the glass of whiskey is somehow suspect. Of course it doesn't help the Irish-American tipplers case any that our biggest holiday involves copious amounts of drinking. Watch out for the drunken Paddy! They'll take over the country with their off-key singing and love of boiled potatoes! Oh well, the good fight must continue to get Irish whiskey the respect it deserves.
    Reply to this
  • 1/25/2010 5:20 PM John Nagle wrote:
    What's wrong with pissn in the sink?
    Reply to this
    1. 1/25/2010 6:41 PM Rich Nagle wrote:
      Strictly speaking, nothing really, aside from matters of hygiene, manners and decorum. The bath or shower drain could be a better alternate, however, as the height, angle and shape of the counter and basin may present proximity-related issues.  Using such logic I suppose you could also wash your face in the toilet given the ready supply of cool, fresh water. I leave this to you to decide.

      I'm really looking forward to the next party at your house.

      Rich

      Reply to this
  • 2/1/2010 6:04 PM Cruiscinlan wrote:
    Hi Rich,

    Thanks for a wonderful and informative article. You capture Irish attitudes to alcohol and drinking culture perfectly. A man (or woman) who takes 8 or 9 pints of porter or fizzy sugary blue/orange/red stuff is the ideal whereas someone who takes a whiskey without ice and sips away is liable to turn into a monster.

    In fact as we all know a large part of negative effects from alcohol may indeed be attributed to sugar (giving drunks lots of energy) various artificial colourings and additives such as caffeine and phenylaline.

    People like yourself (I beg you to forgive the assumption) and myself who take a neat whiskey and a few craft beers and value appreciation and enjoyment do far less harm to ourselves or others than 'regular' drinkers who swill gallons of Bud lite.

    I wish you further success and enjoyment in your hobby and investigation of this fascinating field. I would suggest a copy of 'Truths About Whisky' recently republished on classicexpressions.co.uk as well as the Irish Whiskey Society website.

    Slainte

    Micheal
    Reply to this
Leave a comment

Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.